Manny De Montaigne drinks single malts

all things relating to Michel De Montaigne, Manny being Manny, and single malt scotches

Sunday, May 25, 2008

Name that Drink

Yesterday afternoon, Michael and I were working in the barbeque pit, grilling vegetables for last night's cookout, and quite by accident invented a new drink. I had earlier poured some whisky into a generic juice glass. As everyone knows, we usually drink good whisky out of these crystal highball glasses that Susan found when her parents moved out of their home. I'm certain that the glasses were never used previously, but I figured, if we're going to drink good whisky, why not drink it from a good glass? However, because we were working outside in the pit, I didn't want to risk an accident, so I was using an everyday juice glass. Anyway, Mike asked me did I want to split a Hopdevil with him? (There is a recent posting about Hopedevil, brewed by the Victory Brewing Company.) Of course. So he brought a bottle out from the fridge, and thinking that the brown liquid in my juice glass was the end of en earlier beer, he poured the Hopdevil on top of my malt.

Now maybe a fussier drinker would have poured that mixture out, but I gave it a taste, and lo and behold, it was great. The strong hoppy flavor of the Hopdevil complimented the malt perfectly. I should point out that I wasn't drinking anything great before this happy accident. The malt was this fairly inexpensive 12 year old highland called 'The Speyside'. We bought it because John knows the daughter of the guy who is marketing this whisky in the US. Apparently, It comes from a fairly new distillery, built on the site of an old scotch distillery known as Drumguish. The malt was ok, nothing special, but also reasonably inexpensive, under $30. I point this out only because I'm not sure that anyone would want to use a really fine malt, say Macallan 17, or HP 18, for this new concoction. To mix with beer, probably any malt or even a blended scotch will do. My guess is that the drink is better with a single malt, as Hopdevil's flavor is so strong that it might overpower a milder blend, say Dewars, for example. Another thing I should mention -- This drink has a really distinctive flavor, not for the delicate palate, not in the least bit subtle or understated. Therefore, anything short of barbequed meat, or maybe spicy southwestern food, would be totally overpowered by its taste.

I also don't know the proper proportion of beer to whisky. I'm guessing that Mike's mixture was around four to one, but when I make this next (probably at the next barbeque), I think I'll try six to one, in other words, an ounce of malt for a half bottle of beer.

So that brings us to this question -- what's the name for this new cocktail? I would like readers to chime in and make suggestions, and the winner will receive a free steak dinner, and as much red wine and whisky as he or she wants to go with it, served of course in the back yard. I think I'll hold the voting open until July 31; that will give people plenty of time to experiment, both with names and proportions of whisky to beer. Also, I think it will be good if the matter remains unsettled when we gather at Andy's; this will be an excellent topic of debate and discussion. Far better than then usual political talk that everyone wants to engage in this year. Now this may sound unfair, as I am the sponsor of this contest, but I already thought of my own suggestion for the name - A Hophead. Nevertheless, I am not declaring myself the winner at this early stage, although I don't want a lot of whining and complaining if it turns out that, when all is said and done, I end up winning my own contest. (If that happens, I'll make Susan grill my steak that night.) Anyway, submit your suggestions in the comments. Anyone can participate, and can offer as many names as he or she likes. You can even make suggestions without ever trying the new drink, although that would be a bad idea, only because you would deprive yourself of the opportunity to taste this new cocktail.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

It would seem that a central questions remains unanswered before we can move forward with this experiment. Since by your own admission the whiskey to be used is open (leaving a wide variety of "spice" to be added to the brew)my question is, does the brew need to be the same? If we can use any beer and any whiskey that affords us the opportunity to be extremely creative.

I would take this time to remind you, respectfully, that it is a time honored tradition to drop a shot of whiskey into a beer glass. We of the working class and children of the bowling alley called it a "boilermaker"...daled

8:35 PM  
Blogger pops said...

Yes Danny, we know what a boilermaker is; and cut out this working class horseshit. Despite the bowling heritage, you were no more working class than the rest of us. Not that there would have been anything special about that distinction.
And yes, the beer does matter. For this particular drink, it has to be Hopdevil, just because, by accident, that was the beer that Mike poured on my malt, and also because I suspect that its unique flavor stands up to the strong taste of malt whisky. At this moment, I don't think that the particular whisky makes a difference, only because the stuff I was drinking was nothing special, and also because, as I mentioned, I'm not sure this drink is a sufficient excuse for tampering with the exquisite flavor of some of the better scotches. I'll allow myself to be convinced otherwise, if, for example, someone discovers that the perfect mixture is Hopdevil and say, HP. For now though, any malt whisky will do.

8:23 PM  
Blogger Chuck said...

I'm in.

By the way there is a good article (my point of view) in the 5/28/08 NYT. Page F7 'A Tour of Bitters for the Summer'.

You say that only Hopdevil should be included in the mixture. Question if the single malt used is fairly non-describe then this is a mixture based on the one beer. I'm okay with this since you are starting the competition but are all other beers out of the mixture.

Daled is thinking Hopdevil with other whiskey's and I'm thinking other beers with bottom to middle shelf single malts.

The deadline is good. Please give me a ruling on mixture guideline.

G-man

9:49 AM  
Blogger pops said...

I think the idea here is to limit the beer to Hopdevil. Its really strong flavor is what struck me when Mike accidentally concocted this drink. I'm hypothesizing that the super-strong hoppy flavor is what allows this particular beer not to wilt, when mixed with malt whisky. Its flavor is big enough, and distinctive enough, to mix well with a smoky scotch. And anyway, as Danny points out, otherwise this is just a boilermaker, and it's nothing new or different.

11:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sure I have no business in this discussion, but I'd like to share that Victory Hop Devil was discovered, by accident, by one of my favorite bartenders/whiskey aficionados in Philly. "yeah, they just dropped this case off by mistake, we tried a bottle, liked it, and told the distributor to bring more next time."

We may never know the truth: bureaucratic snafu, deliberate underhanded marketing, the old drug dealer axiom, the first one's always free.....

But we will always know, that this brew, good whiskey, and oppressive heat waves have a way of intersecting, we just have to be ready.

Ubuntu,
Rico

6:46 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home