On the pleasures of malts

"If a hangover came before we got drunk we would see that we never drank to excess: but pleasure, to deceive us, walks in front and hides her train" (On Solitude)

I think that the pursuit of single malt scotch falls perfectly under Montaigne's concept of moderation in seeking pleasure. Scotch is by its nature a vice, yet it actually tempers our appetite for vice. To me, Montaigne argues that we shouldn't prohibit ourselves from vice, but instead use vice as a kind of reward for more honorable aspects of our life. Further, something like Scotch can motivate us during the working hours of the day. "We should retain just enough ocupations and pursuits to keep ourselves fit and to protect ourselves from the unpleasantness which comes in the train of that other extreme: slack and inert idleness". On that note, I'd like to remind us all that we should be sharing our knowledge of Scotches here.

First, I've recently tried the Balvenie 15 and 21. The 21 is actually affordable for the age, and is remarkably smooth and flavorful. I enjoyed the 15 as well. It has a bit of a bite for a 15 year old Highland, but this gave way to a rich flavor and smooth finish. Neither have the caramel nose of a Macallan or Aberlour, which is something I look for in a Highland.

Last Saturday I had the Caol Ila 12, which I thought was amazing. The flavor was peaty, but the color and texture were light and smooth. This would be a good one to introduce a novice to Islay Scotch. I'm looking forward to the 18.

Peace.